CreateMyTee

 

What Our Customers Say

Hear directly from our customers about their experience ordering custom t-shirts and apparel from CreateMyTee!

Reviews at a Glance

Would order again with CreateMyTee

96.4%
Green Star Green Star Green Star Green Star Green Star 66%
Green Star Green Star Green Star Green Star 28%
Green Star Green Star Green Star 5%
Green Star Green Star 0.8%
Green Star 0.1%
Based on 1585 reviews
Updated every 5 minutes
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Alyssa and Steve were so personable and amazing to work with! They both answered all my questions in a timely manner and walked me through the process so everything was extremely easy for me. I couldn't be happier with my artwork, it is incredible! Alyssa took my general idea and turned it into exactly what I had envisioned I couldn't believe it! I also really like how your employees communicate with customers via e-mail, it made me feel like I was a priority and could request/ask anything and get an immediate response! I am very appreciative to my Project Manager and artist and really enjoyed doing business with CreateMyTee!
- Allison K.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Jeremy and Julie were splendid to work with. They did an amazing job with my order, the art was to die for. Jeremy is completely fabulous whenever I had any questions.
- Julie D.
Green StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
They were very helpful.
- Arlene R.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
We loved our design!
- Amber Rae M.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Miles was great - super fast and on top of things!
- Katie B.
Green StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
They did everything they could to give me the best product for the money.
- Arlene R.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Couldn't have been easier. Great customer service. Understood the process.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Kelley is a wonderful employee...you should be proud to have her on your team. She goes out of her way to assist the customer and I am extremely impressed by her customer service skills. I know she's not the artist, but she's the first person a customer comes in contact with. She made our purchase and responded to questions in an expeditious manner. Make sure you keep Kelley on your team! She makes me want to order more t-shirts!
- Sarah D.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Kelley was very helpful. From the day I walk in to the day the order was completed!
- Jerry R.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Easy, as always. Love how open to feedback everyone is. That, and when my creativity is lacking, the artists are quick to jump in with ideas. Love!
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Again, another pleasurable experience with a great product, and again, great help from CreateMyTee staff. However, a couple things that caused some hiccups along the way that I would have not been able to get through without the knowledgeable and expedient Jimmy Hurley and Alyssa Polsinelli.

1. The website doesn't allow you to select different colored shirts/inks in the same order, even though it was an option with the reps I worked with.
2. The website was showing colors that were no longer available (Jade Dome).
3. Related to #1, inability to select custom color/ink combos didn't allow "instant quote" to show a true cost. Later through the order, I had to go back and pay a remaining balance on my order.
4. When "Approving my Artwork" in the Artwork Center, the website didn't allow me to approve custom Names & Numbers that had " " (quotation marks) that I wanted printed, even though it is possible. I would imagine this applies to other special characters? Jimmy told me this was a known issue.
5. I was unaware of the ability to use more than 1 line for custom names on the sleeves of my shirts (at a higher cost, which is understandable), but the website didn't provide any information that it was an option. Jimmy helped me work through it and get exactly what I wanted.

Overall, it was still a fantastic experience with a great product, and all the help I needed from Jimmy Hurley and Alyssa Polsinelli who continually show they go above and beyond to help meet my requirements as the customer.
- Steve K.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
I mentioned this is a comment I sent from the "contact us" section of the website, but Jimmy Hurley and Alyssa Polsinelli were an absolute pleasure to work with. My order was rather complicated, but they worked me through it and helped me get exactly what I needed. They are professional, courteous, and friendly... one of the primary reasons I will continue to go to CreateMyTee for all my custom apparel needs, as well as recommend to others.
- Steve K.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
I love the promptness with responses from my artist.
- Shannon S.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
One of our shirts had a hole in it. This is very unusual and we don't blame you guys. This kind of thing happens occasionally. No worries. We LOVE working with you: great prices and personal contact. I feel like we are friends. And we HAVE recommended you to others and will use you again!
- Jamie B.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
My only constructive critique would be to add more of a selection in the apparel section.
- Brad V.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Very impressed with the delivery turn around time!
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Jimmy was great to work with. Last year I placed an t-shirt order for our softball team and we needed additional shirts this year for new players. Jimmy walked me through each step to get the same type of shirt and logo for the our new players.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Alyssa was extremely helpful, and she made all my changes exactly how I wanted. It was nice being able to email right with her, and I thought it was comforting to be able to see the changes along the way. I've ordered shirts in the past, and after I've sent the info, I was usually just crossing my fingers that it would like right. There was no guess work here. I will definitely be using this site for future orders and recommending it to others!
- Colleen M.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
We had absolutely terrific artists and specialist. The Createmytee staff were more than professional and willing to come to our office to do a personal consultation. This was really helpful in the process because I work part time and was unable to timely respond to emails and messages. The ability to see the colors of the shirts and feel the materials were great. We needed this personal step in order to make our final decision. We will definitely order again.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
The website is not very intuitive. Every time I place an order, I call because Kelley is always helpful and efficient. The website is too much of a bother.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
No
I thought that the experience was great. The only thing we found was the look of our logo from the version on the computer to the version that came on the t-shirt changed. The t-shirt looked great, but it was not quite the colors that we had expected, I think in the future we would probably want to use the number associated with the actual color on our logo to make sure the colors are the same. Again, certainly not an issue on CreateMyTee's side, it was just the way the look transpired from the Artwork Center to our computer.
Green StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
I always have a difficult time when I have to go to a specific website to check out my order status. I would much prefer to have my invoice emailed directly to me. I don't have much time to try to figure out how I have to navigate websites.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
I may have forced your hand because your expertise does not include hats. But because of my successful experience with t-shirts, I was insistent on placing my hat order with you.
- Dale R.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Once again, the process of creating and proofing artwork was simple, fast and efficient. Oftentimes, buyers have to wait days for a proof to be snail-mailed to the office, which delays the process tremendously. The online back-and-forth process of messaging the artist directly and soliciting precise, detailed feedback is incredibly helpful. Linking the proof to Facebook is also a bonus for soliciting feedback from fans/followers of our social media. Highly recommend (and have!) to others.
- Heather E.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
The artist did a good job recommending colors. I thought I knew what colors I was going to use but she suggested light orange instead of dark and it was perfect!
- Jim S.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
We debated about the green vs. blue inks for "Camp Kateri--Summer 2012" on the purple shirts. Julie stated that the blue would read well and that the lime doesn't show up as well on lighter fabrics, so we stayed with the blue. It does look alright, but green would definitely have been better--just FYI for future color choices! :)

Julie was definitely right about not using the underbase for the Kateri staff "vintage" shirts, though! She was definitely great to work with!
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
CreateMyTee was the easiest company that we have worked with in 6 years to order our shirts. We actually switched companies to you guys this year. You guys were quick with the orders and understood that I needed a rush order on shirts, and you guys rushed it! I really appreciate everyone's help over there, you guys saved my butt!! The shirts turned out great and I couldn't beat the price - believe me I tried! I did recommend you guys to a friend of mine that is putting together a bike race because you guys were so awesome!
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
Everything was very easy and both Miles and Jimmy assisted me with all of my picky needs :) They were great!
- Shandy L.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
She was very receptive to the changes we were asking for and was even able to make changes from the logo we uploaded to be used originally.
- Carol J.
Green StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen StarGreen Star
Yes
The artwork process, is -- and always has been -- such an amazingly simple process. The turnaround is remarkably fast and never fails to disappoint. Your artists are talented and open to feedback, no matter how tiny the detail. I'm so grateful to have a company like CreateMyTee.com in the neighborhood to deliver such quality, affordable, stylish t-shirts for our community events! I can't count how many times I've referred people in my line of work (event planning and marketing) to CreateMyTee.com!
- Heather E.